We haven't committed any questionable acts of mayonnaise in a surprisingly long time.
This came out of my great-grandmother's notebook. We've made this recipe before, so let's just zoom in on that last line:
Maybe the mayo on top helps stretch this salad into the purported dozen servings. I know I'd be a bit more cautious with my portion size if I knew my cranberries were buried under mayonnaise.
Despite tossing the idea aside at first, I wondered if cranberry salad is better under mayonnaise-infused whipped cream. After all, I didn't think cranberries and celery were a good idea until I tried that. And mayonnaise and ketchup turn into thousand island dressing instead of a tragedy of condiments.
But I didn't want to purchase an entire bottle of mayonnaise just for one silly salad. But while I was pocketing enough mayonnaise packets for a winter salad, I decided to grab an extra one to complete my great-grandmother's cranberry salad. (Sure, it's a recipe she clipped and not something she independently devised. But that's true for most American family recipes anyway).
![]() |
| It lurks in the cup, atop a single serving of whipped cream... |
I had only one thought: "Well doesn't that just put the mayonnaise on my cranberry sundae?"
![]() |
| It's fruit with whipped cream on top, but with a special surprise... |
There is no place for mayo on top of cranberries. Adding it to whipped
cream makes it extra greasy (you are mixing fat into fat), and it tastes... like mayonnaise. We didn't
get any magical unexpected flavor melding. I'm glad I tried this, but I
am also glad I didn't sink any grocery money into it.
A lot of the recipes "of a certain age" make me think that smoking changed cooking. Like, I think the flavors in this would work if you had pre-tarred your taste buds. (The mayonnaised cream would probably feel less like straight cooking oil on the tongue.) But since we can repaint the ceilings in our house without five coats of post-nicotine primer, I was unimpressed.

Your last paragraph gave me an idea for a truly inspired Google search. According to the Internet, mayonnaise can help remove cigarette tar. It's oil based and can help break it down to be wiped or scraped off a surface. So maybe people were using it to remove the layers of tar so they could taste something. Now imagine someone trying to discreetly scrape their tongue with their spoon after eating the mayonnaise topping off of their salad.
ReplyDeleteOh wow. I never knew that.
DeleteI can imagine that. It goes with the scary "you'll have to shave your hairy tongue" threats they did in school during don't-do-drugs presentations.
At least it looked pretty! (Also, it seemed like a lot of old recipes were convinced something could only count as a salad if mayonnaise were involved in some way.)
ReplyDeleteThey really did. The mayo might not have been so bad on its own, but it got so oily after mixing it with cream.
Delete